Acts of the Mind in Jewish Ritual Law

Acts of the Mind in Jewish Ritual Law
Rav Isaac Cohen z"l
Urim Publications / 870 pages

It is very difficult for me to write a book review on Rabbi Isaac Cohen’s: Acts of the Mind in Jewish Ritual Law. This is because it is a book that I would love to see succeed. However, there a number of deficiencies preventing this from happening.

First let’s discuss what’s good in the book. The book is devoted to explaining the abstract and theoretical concepts in the Talmudic law. There is also much emphasis on contractual law and legal fictions.

There book focuses on 14 different units including, emunah, kedusha, kavana, teshuva, middot, Shabbat, marriage, and more. In each of the units, one will find all the many different terms, principles, and concepts that fall under that category. For example, in the unit on kavana, one will find discussions, explanations, and definitions of topics such as the role of kavana in: yibum, shofar, shechita, prayer, responding amen, Kiddush, marriage, divorce, and much more. Of course, the halachic ramifications in each of these categories are huge. In divorce, one will find discussions of concepts such as: get yashon, bereira, get al tnai, and more. From this perspective, the book serves as a great resource and reference for one who is interested in learning about all the various different concepts and principles that would find themselves within these 14 different units. One gets a good basic exposure to the Talmudic background right through to the practical halacha.

The problem with the book is that it is very “old school” in both style and layout. The English is also very old school, as well. The book was Rav Cohen’s lifetime work. He spent over 25 years preparing it. Rav Cohen died in 2007 at the age of 90, which explains some of the old school feel. He was Irish, and was the Chief Rabbi of Ireland for many years which further illustrates what I mean. As such, one must make a concerted effort to internalize the material when reading it due to the less appealing style of yesteryear’s sefarim. The index is terribly incomplete, lacking entries for many of the important Talmudic concepts that the book sets out to explain! Furthermore, the index only references what chapter the entry can be found in; it does not include the page number, which, in an 800+ page book, makes for a very unfriendly index. Simply put, the book is not on par with today’s “industry standards” with other books of the genre.

Make no mistake, there is a treasury of information contained in its pages, especially appropriate for the layman who wants to expose himself to Talmudic law. I have no doubt that if someone took the initiative to restructure and reconstruct this book, it could be a smashing success. I envision this book being reformatted into an “Encyclopedia of Talmudic Principles”, or something similar. This would be a great project for a sponsor, or family member to oversee.

http://www.urimpublications.com/Merchant2/merchant.mv?Screen=PROD&Store_Code=UP&Product_Code=Acts



Popular posts from this blog

Food: A Halachic Analysis

Image
Food: A Halachic Analysis Rabbi Yehuda Spitz Mosaica, 480 pp I am unsure whether “outstanding,” “remarkable,” or “spectacular,” best describes Rabbi Yehuda Spitz’s sefer “Food: A Halachic Analysis”  -- though all three adjectives may not do justice. In over 30 chapters discussing various food and kashrut related halacha, Rabbi Spitz, a sho’el u’meishiv at Yeshivat Ohr Somayach in Jerusalem, presents unprecedented clarity in explaining and demystifying the issues. Some of these issues include waiting between cheese and meat, using dishwashers for both milk and meat, fish and milk, eggs and onions left uncovered overnight, chalav Yisrael, marit ayin, and much much more. It is thorough, clear, and makes everything easy to understand. Definitely one of his flagship chapters is the appendix on the history of Gelatin and its kosher status. These chapters are not merely regurgitations of what readers have certainly seen in so many other places, but rather, original compositions in the author’
Read more

Sexuality and Jewish Law

Image
Sexuality and Jewish Law Yaakov Shapiro 430 pages In his Sexuality and Jewish Law, Yaakov Shapiro, an ordained rabbi and non-conformist Lubavitcher chassid, offers a thorough, unapologetic, and uncensored presentation of everything relating to sexual activity and Jewish law.  All rabbinic texts that deal with sexual matters are cited along with the interpretations and comments of all the relevant rishonim , achronim , and poskim . There is also a full presentation of the various halachic opinions and resolutions to the contradictions between them. The exhaustive endnotes are essentially an additional book in their own right. While the book is extremely well researched and impressive in its scope, the author clearly has an agenda and bone to pick. As he writes in the introduction, the book was born out of a bad experience and frustrations with what he was being taught in chattan classes and the “one-sided” approach to the laws of intimacy. The author seeks to put an en
Read more

Aggadah: Sages, Stories & Secrets

Image
Aggadah: Sages, Stories, & Secrets Rabbi Immanuel Bernstein Mosaica / 266 pages The Talmudic and Midrashic texts known as Aggadah are the stories, folklore, historical anecdotes, moral exhortations, and practical advice, words of inspiration, and most importantly, Jewish wisdom on how to best live our life in the service of God. In Aggadah: Sages, Stories, & Secrets, Rabbi Immanuel Bernstein, a rebbe in a number of yeshivot and seminaries, takes us on journey through 18 different Haggadic pieces. Some of the topics include free will, inspiration, gratitude, prayer, torah study, mitzva observance, Shabbat, and much more. It is also worth mentioning that the Introduction includes a primer (based on the Rambam [1] ) on the role and authority of Aggada, especially with regard to Aggadic pieces that are sensational, completely unrealistic, or otherwise difficult to digest. Every chapter begins with an Aggadic reading. Then, after asking a number of compelling quest
Read more