Unlocking the Torah Text


Unlocking the Torah Text (Devarim)
Rabbi Shmuel Goldin
OU Press/ Gefen Publishing 311 Pages


Unlocking the Torah Text is a five volume series on the weekly parsha, and I recently received the “Devarim” volume. Although I don’t know the author, Rabbi Shmuel Goldin, personally, I always admired his leadership of the RCA during his tenure as president, especially how no issue was never too big or too small for him to involve himself with. He comes across as a humble and competent leader with the added benefit of advanced scholarship. I jumped at the opportunity to review his work.

Let me begin by specifically mentioning that Unlocking the Torah Text contains three or four different divrei Torah on every parsha. As one who is in the business of reviewing, critiquing, and advising on the publication of Torah sefarim, I can tell you that this is very significant and important. As I tell all aspiring "parsha book" authors who seek my advice: Always include more than one entry per parsha. This way, if the reader does not enjoy one entry on the parsha, he is sure to enjoy something in the second or third entry. Otherwise, if the reader doesn’t enjoy the only entry for two or three consecutive weeks, he is likely going to move on to the "next" parsha book, and not return to your book any time soon. So right there, this book has that advantage: if the first entry on the parsha doesn’t interest you, the second or third entry surely will.

Every chapter opens with an excerpt or theme from the parsha that the chapter will be dealing with. A number of questions are then asked on the excerpt. What follows, however, is what makes this book unique: The question is then answered in accordance with several, often radically different, approaches. There is emphasis on Gemara and the classical meforshim, but there is also no lack of material from the geonim, rishonin, and achronim. At times the differences of opinion are reconciled, at others times, they are left to “agree to disagree”. The chapters conclude with contemporary examples, personal stories, or an anecdote to help solidify the message, leaving readers with further food for thought. 

The author is not shy to bring up “delicate” and “difficult” topics. He readily challenges the Torah's text, and puts the Torah’s characters and episodes in a very real perspective. Some of the highlights of the book include discussions on: who wrote the Torah (Devarim), re-writing history to serve political interests (Devarim), dealing with doubts in one’s faith (Ekev), the legitimacy of eating meat (Re’eh), and rabbinic authority and infallibility (Shoftim), just to name a few. Some entries are halacha related, such as the entries on kriat shema, birkat Hamazon, and hashavat aveida. 

 Here’s an excerpt from parshat Shoftim (this week!):

Context

The Torah opens a review of the laws governing the establishment of a Jewish monarchy with the following two verses: When you come to the land that the Lord your God gives to you, and you possess it and settle in it, and you will say: “I will set over myself a king, like all the nations that surround me.” You shall certainly set over yourselves a king whom the Lord your God shall choose; from among your brethren you shall set over yourselves a king; you cannot place over yourselves a foreign man, who is not your brother. The Talmudic scholars view the appointment of a king as an obligation, one of three positive commandments incumbent on the Israelites upon entry into the land.

Questions

The wording of this mitzva is abundantly strange. Why does the Torah base the appointment of a king on the nation’s expressed desire to “set over myself a king, like all the nations that surround me”? If the establishment of a monarchy is a positive biblical commandment, why doesn’t the Torah simply say: When you come to the land, appoint for yourselves a king? Why would God present a mitzva as developing from the nation’s desire to follow the mores of surrounding societies?The existence of a direct positive commandment to appoint a king also seems to fly in the face of the historical narrative surrounding the selection of Shaul, the first king of Israel. The book of Shmuel clearly records the extreme displeasure with which the prophet Shmuel greeted the nation’s request: “Place for us a king, to judge us like all the nations." Even further, when God commands Shmuel to accede to the nation’s request – but only after informing them of the laws that will govern a future king’s power over them – the prophet clearly uses the opportunity to dissuade the nation from their intended path. If the appointment of the king is a mitzva, why is Shmuel upset with the people’s request and why does he attempt to discourage them from fulfilling this positive biblical commandment?

Approaches

The earliest recorded attempts to address the apparent disconnect between the biblical mitzva to establish a monarchy and Shmuel’s reaction to the nation’s eventual request are found in the Tosefta, a source from the Mishnaic period. There, three possible approaches are presented. 1. An anonymous position postulates that the nation’s request was premature. The time had not yet arrived for the establishment of the monarchy. Rabbi Nehorai maintains that the mitzva to appoint a king is only recorded in the Torah in anticipation of the nation’s future murmurings. For this reason, the Torah hinges the mitzva upon the nation’s expressed desire to “set over myself a king, like all the nations that surround me.” Finally, Rabbi Eliezer the son of Rabbi Yossi argues that the text in the book of Shmuel actually outlines two separate requests that are made of the prophet, one of which was appropriate and one of which was not. The elders first approached Shmuel with the fitting request “Place for us a king, to judge us.” The people then inappropriately added: “[That we may be also] like all the other nations.” Shmuel was not displeased with the elders’ desire to fulfill the mitzva of establishing a monarchy. His upset developed only in response to the people’s improper addendum.

[this essay continues and the ideas are developed in further depth with the Ohr Hachaim, Kli Yakar, and others]

This is not a "Shabbat table" parsha book. It is an in-depth study on some of the more relevant themes in the weekly parsha. It is advanced but accessible, appropriate for scholars and laymen alike.
  

Popular posts from this blog

Food: A Halachic Analysis

Image
Food: A Halachic Analysis Rabbi Yehuda Spitz Mosaica, 480 pp I am unsure whether “outstanding,” “remarkable,” or “spectacular,” best describes Rabbi Yehuda Spitz’s sefer “Food: A Halachic Analysis”  -- though all three adjectives may not do justice. In over 30 chapters discussing various food and kashrut related halacha, Rabbi Spitz, a sho’el u’meishiv at Yeshivat Ohr Somayach in Jerusalem, presents unprecedented clarity in explaining and demystifying the issues. Some of these issues include waiting between cheese and meat, using dishwashers for both milk and meat, fish and milk, eggs and onions left uncovered overnight, chalav Yisrael, marit ayin, and much much more. It is thorough, clear, and makes everything easy to understand. Definitely one of his flagship chapters is the appendix on the history of Gelatin and its kosher status. These chapters are not merely regurgitations of what readers have certainly seen in so many other places, but rather, original compositions in the aut...
Read more

Sexuality and Jewish Law

Image
Sexuality and Jewish Law Yaakov Shapiro 430 pages In his Sexuality and Jewish Law, Yaakov Shapiro, an ordained rabbi and non-conformist Lubavitcher chassid, offers a thorough, unapologetic, and uncensored presentation of everything relating to sexual activity and Jewish law.  All rabbinic texts that deal with sexual matters are cited along with the interpretations and comments of all the relevant rishonim , achronim , and poskim . There is also a full presentation of the various halachic opinions and resolutions to the contradictions between them. The exhaustive endnotes are essentially an additional book in their own right. While the book is extremely well researched and impressive in its scope, the author clearly has an agenda and bone to pick. As he writes in the introduction, the book was born out of a bad experience and frustrations with what he was being taught in chattan classes and the “one-sided” approach to the laws of intimacy. The author seeks to put a...
Read more

Aggadah: Sages, Stories & Secrets

Image
Aggadah: Sages, Stories, & Secrets Rabbi Immanuel Bernstein Mosaica / 266 pages The Talmudic and Midrashic texts known as Aggadah are the stories, folklore, historical anecdotes, moral exhortations, and practical advice, words of inspiration, and most importantly, Jewish wisdom on how to best live our life in the service of God. In Aggadah: Sages, Stories, & Secrets, Rabbi Immanuel Bernstein, a rebbe in a number of yeshivot and seminaries, takes us on journey through 18 different Haggadic pieces. Some of the topics include free will, inspiration, gratitude, prayer, torah study, mitzva observance, Shabbat, and much more. It is also worth mentioning that the Introduction includes a primer (based on the Rambam [1] ) on the role and authority of Aggada, especially with regard to Aggadic pieces that are sensational, completely unrealistic, or otherwise difficult to digest. Every chapter begins with an Aggadic reading. Then, after asking a number of compelling q...
Read more